Find your next favourite story now
Login

Pumpkin spice - yay or nay?

last reply
25 replies
5.5k views
0 watchers
0 likes
In baked good only, esp. pies. I have had pumpkin spice teas and they just didn't do it for me. Though that's partly just me being me. I tend to prefer fruit flavoured teas to spice teas in general.

Can she find the silence again?

Scream Away The Silence - The Sound of Silence comp entry

I've never tried it

Am I missing out?
Quote by Welshdreamer42
I've never tried it

Am I missing out?


You aren't missing out, in my opinion.

While I do like a pumpkin spice mixture — cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, allspice and cloves — in some baked goods, I find it nasty in a latte. Starbucks makes a HUGE deal about its Pumpkin Spice Latte, though, and a lot of people like it. I think Pumpkin Spice has become way overdone in the U.S. It's in everything.
Connect with Maggie

Like my Facebook fan pages: Maggie Rascal and M.P. WitwerFriend me on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/maggierascalFollow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/Maggie1Rascal
I've only ever used the spices considered "pumpkin" in a pumpkin pie. When doing that I use the usual suspects, i.e. cinnamin, ginger, and nutmeg. I've never used that combo in anything else. I hear about the controversy each year but it's never been presented to me personally. I don't really have an educated opinion. I just think it is like so many other things in our culture, something to be overhyped to make money. I'll keep using the spices when I make my pies, and pretty much ignore the whole thing, otherwise.
Quote by magnificent1rascal
I think Pumpkin Spice has become way overdone in the U.S. It's in everything.


Alas, it's not just the US. It's up here, too.ZObdujcpgf4j5uzc

Can she find the silence again?

Scream Away The Silence - The Sound of Silence comp entry

Pumpkin spice latte, yummy!!
I had no idea what it was, (it hasn't shown up here either), so I googled it. Aromatic spices best used sparingly in baked goods, as far as I'm concerned.

Coffee, I make with a stove top espresso pot, and drink it black, no millk, no sugar. It's the way we like it here.
In Austria and neighboring countries (I know in some cases), they have 3 kinds of coffee: Expresso/espresso, cinnamon, and "filter" coffee.
Here in New England we have Pumpkin pie with some of the spices mentioned here, and Squash pie. I prefer Squash pie as it is milder.
But to take any of these spices and put them into a latte seems "overkill."
I’m the one who makes the pumpkin pies for thanksgiving. By the time I’m done the smell is overwhelming to me. Someone gave me a pumpkin spice candle and I regifted it fast. Shhh don’t tell okay?
Pumpkin spice baked goods, OK. But lattes? No.
I say yes. I don't drink them every season, but a yes from me.

Pumpkin spice latte has to come from Dunkin Donuts and bought in mid-October to me

www.szadventures.com



It exist but we don't coexist. 





Someone on another board mentioned getting a pumpkin spice Blizzard at Dairy Queen. That I could probably get behind.

Can she find the silence again?

Scream Away The Silence - The Sound of Silence comp entry

P.S. deodorant and toothpaste. Yummee.

Iconoclastically incorrigible or just a silly dumb ass...

So you want to SMELL like pumpkin spice? I mean, toothpaste I can kind of see (not my cuppa, but I can sort of see it) but deodorant??

Can she find the silence again?

Scream Away The Silence - The Sound of Silence comp entry

I posted in this thread 2 years ago to say I hadn’t tried it. Still haven’t 🙄

I don't drink coffee, so I don't have any experience in that department, but I don't mind it in baked goods. The problem is it's showing up in everything else. My son brought pumpkin spice tortilla chips and pumpkin spice Triscuits to our vacation. They were not popular. 

I say, yes.

We. Are. So. Done.

Pumpkin pie. Pumpkin bread. That’s it.

Iconoclastically incorrigible or just a silly dumb ass...

I had never had pumpkin spice anything for years until last year when I tried a pumpkin spiced granola bar from Sunbelt and I would like to say it's... um an ok flavor 😊

Nay.



"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it." George Santayana

In pies, muffins, and breads, they're OK, but beyond that, I say N A Y.

Still Nay! 😎



"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it." George Santayana